MIME-Version: 1.0 Content-Type: multipart/related; boundary="----=_NextPart_01D7D174.3FC8E160" Este documento é uma Página da Web de Arquivo Único, também conhecido como Arquivo Web. Se você estiver lendo essa mensagem, o seu navegador ou editor não oferece suporte ao Arquivo Web. Baixe um navegador que ofereça suporte ao Arquivo Web. ------=_NextPart_01D7D174.3FC8E160 Content-Location: file:///C:/DE7559EC/1176-Textodoartigo-ENHTML.htm Content-Transfer-Encoding: quoted-printable Content-Type: text/html; charset="windows-1252"
PREVALENCE OF PERIPHERAL ARTERIAL DISEASE IN PEOPLE
WITH DIABETES MELLITUS: SYSTEMATIC REVIEW AND METHANALYSIS
PREVALÊNCIA DE DOENÇA ART=
ERIAL
PERIFÉRICA EM PESSOAS COM DIABETES MELLITUS: REVISÃO SISTEMÁTICA E METANÁLI=
SE
Brenda Sales=
Lins[1]
* Juliana Andreia Fernandes Noronha[2]
* Sheila Milena Pessoa dos Sant=
os[3] Thaynara Tavares
Oliveira Ramos[4] * Taciana
da Costa Farias Almeida[5]
* Roberta
Lima Gonçalves[6]
RESUMO
Objetivo: Estimar a prevalência da Doe=
nça
Arterial Periférica em indivíduos com Diabetes Mellitus por meio de evidênc=
ias
da literatura. Método: Revisão sistemática e metanálise, realizad=
as por
dois pesquisadores independentes, em bases de dados nacionais e internacion=
ais.
O protocolo da revisão seguiu as recomendações PRISMA e foi registrado na b=
ase
International Prospective =
Register
of Systematic Reviews (PROSPERO). Foram incluídos artigos publicados nos
últimos cinco anos, e a qualidade metodológica foi avaliada através do
instrumento proposto pelo The
Joanna Briggs Institute, que avalia estudos de =
prevalência. Na metanálise utilizou-se o =
modelo
de efeitos randômicos, assim como análises para investigação de
heterogeneidade. Resultados: F=
oram
analisados 2408 estudos, que, após aplicados os critérios de elegibilidade,
totalizaram 14 artigos, no qual todos realizaram o teste do índice
tornozelo-braço para o diagnóstico da Doença Arterial Periférica. A amostra
total foi de 9335 pessoas, prevalência de 6.30% de DAP, e a heterogeneidade=
do
estudo foi I² =3D 97%. Na análise de subgrupos, as mulheres, pessoas com ma=
is de
5 anos de diabetes, hipertensão e obesidade apresentaram maior prevalência =
de
doença arterial periférica. Conclu=
são:
Esse estudo demonstra que a
prevalência da Doença Arterial Periférica entre os pacientes diabéticos é
relevante, principalmente entre as mulheres. O teste do índice tornozelo-br=
aço
é amplamente indicado e útil para avaliação do paciente diabético e diagnós=
tico
precoce da Doença Arterial Periférica e pode contribuir para a prevenção de
feridas e amputação, proporcionado melhor qualidade vi=
da.Palavras-chave: Doença
Arterial Periférica; Diabetes mellitus; Prevalência; Índice Tornozelo-Braço;
Cuidados de Enfermagem.
ABSTRACT
Aim:<=
/span> To
estimate the prevalence of Peripheral Arterial Disease in individuals with
Diabetes Mellitus using evidence from the literature. Method: Systematic review and meta-analysis, carried out by two
independent researchers, in national and international databases. The review
protocol followed PRISMA recommendations and was registered in the
International Prospective Register of Systematic Reviews (PROSPERO). Articl=
es
published in the last five years were included, and the methodological qual=
ity
was assessed using the instrument proposed by The Joanna Briggs Institute,
which assesses prevalence studies. In the meta-analysis, the random effects
model was used, as well as analyzes to investigate heterogeneity.
Key
words: Peripheral Arterial Disease; Diabetes Mellitus;
Prevalence; Ankle Brachial Index; Nursing Care.
INTRODUCTION
Diabetes Mellitus (DM) is a disease of high morbidity and mortality,=
of
multifactorial origin, characterized by persistent hyperglycemia, which cau=
ses
systemic consequences1. More than 463 million people worldwide live with a
diagnosis of DM, 90% of which is type 2². DM often causes vascular
complications, including Peripheral Arterial Disease (PAD), considered one =
of
the causes for major lower limb amputations3. A PAD, when associated with
neuropathy and foot ulceration, increases the risk of gangrene and limb
amputation4.
PAD stands out for a gradual reduction in blood flow due to occlusive
factors in arterial beds5. It is an atherosclerotic disease with more
prevalence among the elderly and may be asymptomatic in the vast majority of
cases, however, there is the potential to progress with clinical symptoms, =
such
as lameness, and eventually lead to tissue necrosis6.
The diagnosis of PAD must include a thorough physical examination, w=
hich
involves an investigation of clinical signs, such as the absence of periphe=
ral
pulses, arterial thrills and changes in the skin of the affected limb, in
addition to verifying the severity of the vascular obstruction, specified by
the ankle-brachial index (ITB) 7. The ABI is efficient for the detection of
peripheral blood flow obstruction in the lower limbs and for the diagnosis =
of
PAD, which is given by the relationship between the systolic blood pressure=
in
the posterior or pedios tibial artery and the s=
ystolic
pressure in the brachial artery8 .
The use of the ITB for the diagnosis of PAD is low-cost, non-invasive
and easy to operate by any healthcare professional, including a trained and
trained nurse. This assessment can be performed at the time of the consulta=
tion,
and important information can be provided for clinical practice in Primary
Health Care (PHC) 9. Thus, early diagnosis is extremely important, as it al=
lows
for prior treatment, in order to avoid complications10.
Thus, in order for health professionals to act preventively in PHC,
there is a need to investigate the prevalence of this pathology in this
specific population in the literature, since it is a common condition, subj=
ect
to early assessment and intervention.
Thereby, it is possible to build a foundation for prevention measures
and minimize complications of PAD.
Given the above, therefore, this study aims to estimate the prevalen=
ce
of Peripheral Arterial Disease in individuals with Diabetes Mellitus throug=
h a
systematic review with meta-analysis.
METHODS
It consists of a systematic review study with meta-analysis elaborat= ed and written according to the PRISMA (Preferred Reporting Items for Systemat= ic Reviews and Meta-Analyzes) recommendations, in order to mitigate the risk of bias. The review protocol was registered in the International Prospective Register of Systematic Reviews (PROSPERO) under the number CRD42020196384.<= o:p>
The research question included the criteria established by the acron=
ym
PICo, being considered: P – Adult individuals; I – Prevalence of Peripheral
Arterial Disease; Co – Individuals with Type 2 Diabetes Mellitus. Thus, this
research sought to answer the following question: What is the prevalence of
Peripheral Arterial Disease in individuals with Type 2 Diabetes Mellitus?
Original articles were included in the sample, cross-sectional studi=
es,
which investigated the prevalence of PAD in adult patients with type 2 DM;
studies published in the last 5 years, in English, Portuguese and Spanish, =
with
full text available. Studies that dealt with PAD but that the target popula=
tion
were not adult diabetic patients were excluded. Furthermore, the authors ch=
ose
to exclude theses, dissertations and monographs.
Regarding the sources of information and search strategies, the
selection of studies was performed in the following databases: Medical
Literature Analysis and Retrieval System Online (MEDLINE), consulted by the=
US
National Library of Medicine National Institute of Health (PubMed), Cumulat=
ive
Index to Nursing & Allied Health Literature (CINAHL) and SCOPUS, using =
the
Journal Portal of the Coordination for the Improvement of Higher Education
Personnel (CAPES). In addition to these, the Nursing Database (BDENF), the
Latin American and Caribbean Literature on Health Sciences (LILACS), the
Spanish Bibliographic Index of Health Sciences (IBECS) and the Caribbean
Literature in Health Sciences (MEDCARIB), which were examined through the
Virtual Health Library (VHL).
The selection of studies was carried out between December 2019 and M=
ay
2020, and for the search in the databases, the following descriptors were
combined: Ankle Brachial Index, Peripheral Arterial Disease, Diabetes Melli=
tus,
in Portuguese, English and Spanish. The descriptors classified were those
controlled and available by the Medical Subject Headings (MeSH) and Health
Sciences Descriptors (DeCS).
According to the eligibility criteria, two authors independently
selected the studies and evaluated the titles and abstracts. Then, the sele=
cted
studies were analyzed in full, in which disagreements were resolved by
consensus. To extract data from the studies, an Excel spreadsheet was creat=
ed,
and the variables of interest to the study were recorded: authors, year of
publication, place of publication, prevalence of PAD, sample with PAD, total
sample, sex, age, duration DM, SAH, dyslipidemia, BMI, smoking, presented
symptoms and diagnostic method.
Regarding the assessment of the methodological quality of the includ=
ed
studies, the instrument used to assess the quality of prevalence studies was
proposed by The Joanna Briggs Institute – JBI, with adaptations. The follow=
ing
criteria were adopted: 1) Was the sample appropriate to address the target
population?; 2) Were study participants properly sampled?; 3) Was the sample
size adequate?; 4) Were the subjects and environment described in detail?; =
5)
Was the data analysis conducted with sufficient coverage based on the sampl=
e?;
6) Were valid methods used to identify the disease?; 7) Was the condition
measured in a standard and reliable way for all participants?; 8) Was there=
an
adequate statistical analysis?; 9) Was the response rate adequate?. For each
criterion met, the study received a point, in which the quality assessment =
was
not used as an exclusion criterion for the articles.
The outcome analyzed in this study was Peripheral Arterial Disease
(PAD), with the adoption of a 95% confidence interval. The forest plot and
funnel graph were analyzed using the R software, version 3.6.2.
The assessment of heterogeneity between studies was measured by the
Cochran Q test, which is based on the chi-square, in which a p-value less t=
han
0.05 considers present heterogeneity. The I2 analysis was performed to test=
the
degree of heterogeneity, and it was also evaluated through the analysis of
subgroups (gender, duration of DM, hypertension, obesity and smoking). The
funnel plot and the Egger test assessed the presence of publication bias am=
ong
the studies that comprised the sample.
RESULTS
After a thorough analysis, the search strategy retrieved 2408 studie=
s,
of which 2295 did not meet the inclusion criteria, totaling 113 articles, w=
hich
after being screened, remained a total of 14 articles included in the review
and meta-analysis for meeting the eligibility criteria. Detai=
ls of t=
he selection process are
Figure 1 – Process of identification and inclusio=
n of
studies in the databases, Campina Grande, PB, Brazil, 2020
Source: The authors
When considering the studies included in the analysis, it was observ=
ed
that India was the country with the highest number of publications on the
prevalence of PAD in people with type 2 DM, totaling 28.5%, whose years of
greatest publications were 2014 and 2019, both with 28.5%. In addition, in
total, approximately 9335 people with type 2 DM were evaluated in the studi=
es
that comprised the sample. The diagnostic method applied in all studies was=
the
ABI, which used the value <0.9 as PAD as a parameter, considered a strat=
egy
effective in the early diagnosis of PAD, shown in Table 1.
Table 1 - Characteristics
of the studies included in the systematic review on the prevalence of PAD in
people with type II DM. Campina Grande, PB,
Brazil, 2020.
Author |
Year |
Place |
Total Sample |
Age group |
Quality score |
Diagnostic method |
Pattern used |
Arora
et al26 |
2019 |
India |
317 |
≥ 30 |
8 |
ITB |
<1,00 |
Felício et al27 |
2019 |
Brazil |
711 |
≥ 30 |
9 |
ITB |
≤ 0,9 |
Yuan
et al28 |
2019 |
China |
1018 |
Average 58,59 |
9 |
ITB |
<0,9 |
Weerarathna et al29 |
2019 |
Sri Lanka |
2423 |
≥ 18 |
9 |
ITB |
≤ 0,9 |
Shukla
et al115 |
2018 |
India |
200 |
Average 57 |
9 |
ITB |
≤ 0,9 |
Moreira
et al5 |
2017 |
Brazil |
249 |
≥ 18 |
9 |
ITB |
≤ 0,9 |
Amissah; Antiri18 |
2016 |
Gana |
200 |
≥ 20 |
8 |
ITB |
≤ 0,9 |
Garg
et al13 |
2016 |
India |
67 |
≥ 30 |
8 |
ITB |
≤ 0,9 |
Li et al30 =
|
2016 |
China |
1028 |
Average 62 |
9 |
ITB |
<0,9 |
Sales
et al31 |
2015 |
Brazil |
73 |
Average 55,7 |
9 |
ITB |
≤ 0,9 |
Monterroso et al32 |
2014 |
Spain |
251 |
≥ 50 |
9 |
ITB |
≤ 0,9 |
Continue
Continuation=
span> – Table 1.
Author |
Year |
Place |
Total Sample |
Age group |
Quality score |
Diagnostic method |
Pattern used |
Okello
et al33 |
|
Uganda |
229 |
≥ 50 |
9 |
ITB |
≤ 0,9 |
Pinaya et al34 |
2014 |
Bolivia |
76 |
- |
8 |
ITB |
<0,9 |
Eschol
et al12 |
2014 |
India |
2493 |
≥ 20 |
8 |
ITB |
≤ 0,9 |
Source: The authors
It is observed, in the figure below, figure 2, that, referring to the
population analyzed, a prevalence of PAD of 6.30% was estimated (95%CI =3D =
3.21 –
11.99).
Figure 2 - Forest plot chart of Peripheral Arterial Disease
prevalence among the analyzed studies. Campina Grande, PB, Brazil, 2020.
=
=
Source: The authors
The figure 3 Represents=
the
funnel plot, which also displays data on the prevalence of PAD, according to
the standard error, showing asymmetry between the evaluated studies. Such
evidence is confirmed by the Egger Test (p=3D0.13), which shows a non-signi=
ficant
value, indicating that there is no bias between publications.
Figure 3 - <=
span
lang=3DEN-US style=3D'font-size:12.0pt;font-family:"Times New Roman",serif;
mso-fareast-font-family:"Times New Roman";color:black;mso-font-kerning:14.0=
pt;
mso-ansi-language:EN-US;mso-fareast-language:EN-CA'>Funnel chart for the
distribution of the prevalence of Peripheral Arterial Disease, according to=
the
manuscripts investigated. Campina Grande, PB, Brazil, 2020.
Source: The authors
In the analysis of
subgroups, there is a higher prevalence of PAD among the female population
(20.4%). Furthermore, it was possible to identify a correlation between the
duration of DM and PAD, in which 16.7% had DM between 5 – 10 years and 16.3%
had it for more than 10 years. Furthermore, it is clear that smoking was not
evidenced as a factor related to the development of PAD among the studies in
the sample.
In order to analyze the
possible causes of heterogeneity among the included studies, subgroup analy=
zes
were performed, as described in Table 2. It is observed that the articles
presented data regarding the absence of obesity, showing a homogeneity
confirmed by I2 =3D 0.0 %. The other analyzes showed a high heterogeneity,
however, they did not demonstrate the causes for the divergences between the
data studied.
Table 2 - Distribution of the prevalence of peripheral
arterial disease by subgroups. Campina Grande, PB, Bra=
zil,
2020.
Subgroups |
Number of studies ** |
Total of participants |
Prevalence (%) |
IC95% |
I2 (%) |
p-value* |
Gender |
|
|
|
|
|
|
Female |
10 |
3515 |
20,4 |
15,6-26,4 |
92,0 |
<0,01 |
Male |
10 |
4479 |
18,8 |
14,3-24,3 |
91,0 |
<0,01 |
Duration of DM |
|
|
|
|
|
|
5
- 10 years |
6 |
6394 |
16,7 |
13,7-20,1 |
87,0 |
<0,01 |
Over
10 years |
3 |
1469 |
16,3 |
4,8-42,8 |
98,0 |
<0,01 |
Hipertension |
|
|
|
|
|
|
Yes |
7 |
3162 |
13,1 |
9,0-18,6 |
95,0 |
<0,01 |
No |
7 |
2143 |
11,8 |
7,6-18,8 |
86,0 |
<0,01 |
Tabagism |
|
|
|
|
|
|
Yes |
7 |
1050 |
2,5 |
1,7-3,7 |
69,0 |
<0,01 |
No |
7 |
4244 |
18,3 |
13,4-24,4 |
93,0 |
<0,01 |
Obesity |
|
|
|
|
|
|
Yes |
3 |
316 |
10,2 |
5,7-17,6 |
77,0 |
0,01 |
No |
3 |
251 |
18,4 |
14,1-23,8 |
0,0 |
0,46 |
*Chi-square test; No.:
Number; CI: Confidence Interval; DM: Diabetes Mellitus.
** In the analysis of
subgroups, only studies that brought the association of the variable with P=
AD
were included, so the sum does not necessarily give 14 studies.
Source: The authors
DISCUSSION
Understood as a challenge for patients and health team professionals=
in
PHC, PAD requires specific care for prevention, identification of signs and
symptoms and etiological factors. In this sense, the importance of early
detection through the ABI is highlighted, considered an important indicator=
of
PAD in its asymptomatic phase11.
In the present study, a prevalence of 6.30% of PAD was found in pati=
ents
with type 2 DM. A lower prevalence of 0.66% was found in one study (95%CI 0=
.40
– 1.07) 12, while a considerably higher prevalence of 40.15 % was obtained =
in
another study (95%CI 29.16 – 52.23) 13. This high variability of PAD preval=
ence
found in the literature can be explained by the different research sites, by
concentrating people with different types of complications, by the age of t=
he
participants, time elapsed before diagnosis and types of tests used for
diagnosis.
Although not a high prevalence (6.3%), the result presented has a
relevant clinical value due to the high morbidity and mortality of the dise=
ase.
It also demonstrates the important association between PAD and DM, related =
to
the duration of DM, systemic arterial hypertension (SAH), smoking and obesi=
ty,
considered risk factors for cardiovascular events. These results corroborate
published studies 6,14 that demonstrated that the main risk factors for the
development of PAD would be DM, smoking, SAH and obesity. It is justified t=
hat
such factors deteriorate the vascular endothelium and stimulate an inflamma=
tory
reaction in the vessel wall.
A high heterogeneity (I² =3D 97%) was identified between the studies,
which can be explained by the inequalities between the selected articles,
indicated by the Egger Test (p=3D0.13). Furthermore, the heterogeneity can =
be justified
by the differences in the scenario of the included studies, the sample
difference, as well as the defined time frame.
In the present study, a relationship between gender and the prevalen=
ce
of PAD was observed, in which a greater number of women (24%) had the disea=
se.
This result converges with other studies that observed a higher prevalence =
of
PAD among women, considered to be the most important predictor of the patho=
logy
12,15. This is justified by the fact that women in menopause have a decreas=
e in
estrogen production, which contributes to the atherosclerotic process, due =
to
changes in the vascular wall, causing a greater cardiovascular risk, which =
can
be aggravated by other comorbidities16.
With regard to the duration of DM, the data show that the prevalence=
of
PAD is directly proportional to its course, and represents an important risk
factor for the worsening of the disease. In this study, it is demonstrated =
that
the predominance of PAD was greater among people who had more than five yea=
rs
of DM. This result was also found in other studies that demonstrate that DM
complications occur after five years of diagnosis17. In a study carried out=
in
India15, it was identified that the prevalence of PAD was significantly hig=
her
in patients with diabetes for a longer period. Thus, it can be stated that =
PAD
progresses more quickly in people with DM, and its prevalence increases with
advancing age and duration of diabetes 13,18.
Still on cardiovascular complications, it is known that SAH is
associated with vascular diseases and arteriosclerotic complications, and t=
his
study found a higher prevalence of SAH in people with PAD. Another study
demonstrated that there is an association between SAH and high mortality ra=
tes
in patients with PAD19, as was also evidenced by a study carried out in Bra=
zil,
that there was a significant correlation between PAD and hypertension, in
which, in its sample , 83.5% of patients had both comorbidities5. In the
selection of articles included in this review, 50% of the studies showed th=
is
risk factor associated with PAD.
In the present study, there was a low number of smokers, which can be
explained by the low rate of smokers in the included sample and by the grea=
ter
awareness of people over the years regarding the risks of smoking. However,=
it
is known that smoking is associated with numerous diseases and is considered
the risk factor that most contributes to the development of PAD, as well as
being related to the progression and acceleration of acute arterial
occlusions14. This result corroborates another study that demonstrated the
association between smoking and PAD20. This association can be explained by=
the
fact that smoking directly damages the vascular endothelium, causing struct=
ural
damage and endothelial dysfunction. In turn, it is essential that diabetic
patients stop smoking, considering that it is one of the measures that has =
the
greatest impact in reducing the risk of complications21.
By analyzing the samples studied in each article, it was found that
three of the selected studies addressed obesity as a risk factor for the
development of PAD. It is known that obesity increases the risk of metabolic
syndrome, which is linked to several clinical conditions and risk factors f=
or
the development of cardiovascular diseases. It was previously demonstrated =
by
other studies that obesity was the most prevalent risk factor, being consid=
ered
an independent factor for the development of cardiovascular diseases22. In
addition, obesity was shown to be present in another study, affecting more =
than
75% of the population evaluated23. According to the Brazilian Society of
Diabetes24, most individuals living with type 2 DM are obese, thus, this
population is more vulnerable to the development of PAD.
In addition, this injury represents a relevant economic impact on the
health system, as it demands a high cost to control and treat complications.
Among them, PAD, associated with DM, increases the risk of amputations,
impairing the quality of life of individuals with the pathology, as well as=
overloading
the health system25.
Thus, it is understood that the role of the PHC team in assisting the
individual with DM is essential, considering that it contributes to the
planning of health promotion and disease prevention actions, in addition to
acting directly in care. Health education stands out as an important factor=
for
the prevention and treatment of complications arising from DM. By performing
the ABI, it is possible to identify early PAD in its asymptomatic phase, in
order to minimize the morbidity and mortality of the complication. In addit=
ion,
Primary Health Care is highlighted as a place for monitoring the patient wi=
th
DM, and in this scenario the identification of risk factors, blood glucose
levels and monitoring of health care of the population, aiming to identify =
and
minimize the factors of risk for the development of complications26.
The limitations of this systematic review study refer to the variabi=
lity
of the articles included and the scenarios of each research, covering the
sample difference, different time frames and heterogeneous populations. Ano=
ther
limitation is the number of studies retrieved, which can be justified by the
temporal filter applied.
Despite the limitations, this study can contribute both to the acade=
mic
environment and to the qualification of actions in Primary Health Care. By
identifying the prevalence of PAD among individuals with DM, through the AB=
I,
and the association between risk factors pathology, the study can favor the
planning of public policies and strategies, in order to minimize the
complications of DM, as well as the costs generated by the treatment of
complications.
CONCLUSION
This study demonstrates that the prevalence of PAD among diabetic
patients is relevant, especially among women. Despite the challenges observ=
ed,
it is believed that this study represents an initial effort to systematize
information on the diagnosis of PAD, the main indicator of difficult-to-heal
wounds and amputation in diabetic patients. It was found that the ABI is wi=
dely
indicated and useful for the assessment of patients with DM and that it can=
be
performed by health professionals, including nurses, trained and trained and
can contribute to the prevention of diseases in this population, providing
better quality of life for individuals and minimizing costs related to
hospitalization and treatment of possible complications.
The results also suggest that there are gaps between risk factors and
PAD in relation to age that need to be investigated in this population of
diabetics. It is also suggested that new studies should present, in additio=
n to
strict design, an adequate sample size that allows a statistical comparison
between the variables and application of standardized instruments to monitor
the results in the long term. It is considered that other studies of this
nature will make it possible to identify groups of diabetics at higher risk=
for
the development of PAD, and to plan health promotion and intervention actio=
ns
aimed fundamentally at maintaining and improving the quality of health care=
for
this group of patients.
REFERENCES
Corresponding author
Brenda
Sales Lins. Rua Aloísio Batista da Silva, 115 A, Bodoc=
ongó,
58429-625. (83) 98793-8320, salesbrenda0@gmail.com
Submission: 2021-07-15
Approval: 2021-10-26
[1]=
Acadêmica de
Enfermagem da Universidade
Federal de Campina Grande, Campina Grande, Brasil. https://orcid.org/0000-0002-4552-1788
[2] Doutora em
enfermagem pela Universidade Federal de Minas Gerais. Docente Adjunto da
Universidade Federal de Campina Grande, Campina Grande, Brasil. https://orcid.org/0000-0002-2990-7744
[3]=
Doutora em
enfermagem pela Universidade Federal de Minas Gerais. Docente Adjunto da
Universidade Federal de Campina Grande, Campina Grande, Brasil. https://orcid.org/0000-0001-=
9396-9192
[4] Acadêmica de
Enfermagem da Universidade
Federal de Campina Grande, Campina Grande, Brasil. https://orcid.org/0000-0001-8931-1312
[5]=
Doutora em
enfermagem pela Universidade Federal da Paraíba. Docente Adjunto da
Universidade Federal de Campina Grande, Campina Grande, Brasil. https://orcid.org/0000-0002-=
9390-9656
[6] Doutora em
enfermagem pela Universidade Federal de Minas Gerais. Docente Adjunto da
Universidade Federal de Campina Grande, Campina Grande, Brasil. https://orcid.org/0000-0002-8074-4610
= =